Is Posting Shift Schedules Allowed? Data Privacy in Shift Scheduling
What Do Data Privacy and Shift Scheduling Have in Common? Is the shift schedule even considered a document that falls under data privacy regulations? Learn more about it in this article.
Table of Contents
- Data Privacy and Shift Scheduling
- Is Posting Shift Schedules Prohibited?
- What Does the Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG) Say?
- Personal Data in Shift Schedules
- Access Management in shyftplan
- Data Privacy in Shift Scheduling
- Shift Schedule Posting – Employee Consent
Data Privacy and Shift Scheduling
Data privacy has become increasingly important for both companies and individuals in recent years. As we navigate the internet and share personal information more frequently, handling this data with care has become essential.
But what does data privacy have to do with shift scheduling? Is the shift schedule even considered a document subject to data privacy regulations? Today, we aim to shed light on this topic.
Is Posting Shift Schedules Prohibited?
In many workplaces, it is common practice to publicly display the shift schedule, making it visible to all employees. This is often done in meeting or break rooms, or on a bulletin board. However, some companies are moving away from this practice due to data privacy concerns.
For employees, this can be particularly problematic if tasks such as shift swaps, vacation planning, or even (over)time tracking were previously managed through the publicly displayed shift schedule. Additionally, employees are often no longer permitted to copy or photograph the shift schedule.
How Siemens Energy Boosted Efficiency and Satisfaction with AI-Driven Shift Scheduling
Siemens Energy is a pioneer in implementing AI-powered shift scheduling, demonstrating how automated solutions can enhance both efficiency and satisfaction. Discover how the company revolutionized its shift scheduling with shyftplan, increasing machine utilization by 50% and achieving a 98% employee satisfaction rate. Learn more about this success story in detail in our whitepaper.
Posting Shift Schedules – What Does the Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG) Say?
Does the Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG) apply to shift schedules? Is it explicitly forbidden to publicly display a shift schedule within a company, or to copy or photograph it? The BDSG regulates the handling of personal data and implements the EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in Germany. According to §4 BDSG, every individual has the right to determine who can access their personal data, as well as how and when it can be used. Violations of these data protection rights can result in fines of up to €50,000.
Personal Data in Shift Schedules
Shift schedules are classified as documents containing personal data. These include full names, addresses, birthdates, work schedules, vacation and sick days, and overtime records.
Such data cannot be publicly disclosed within a company without safeguards. Misuse of this data could lead to internal disputes over overtime or vacation allocation, or security risks, such as revealing when an employee is on vacation, potentially inviting burglars. Even with good intentions, it remains the employee's right to decide whether to share personal data like work hours, overtime, and vacation days with colleagues.
Access Management in shyftplan
In shyftplan, data privacy is ensured through access management, which controls visibility and editing rights for each employee. This system ensures that employees only see and modify the information necessary for their work while protecting other employees’ data. Effective access management safeguards personal data without compromising the functionality of the shift schedule, forming a solid foundation for data privacy within the organization.
Data Privacy in Shift Scheduling
So, is publicly posting a shift schedule explicitly prohibited? The answer is nuanced: yes and no.
If you want to post a shift schedule, anonymization or pseudonymization can be used. This ensures the data cannot be easily linked to specific individuals. Employees can still see their shifts without knowing the schedules of others. The same principle applies to vacation plans or logged overtime. However, anonymization or pseudonymization does not assist with shift swapping or finding replacements for unexpected absences—alternative solutions are needed in such cases.
Shift Schedule Posting – Employee Consent
Another way to enable the posting of a shift schedule is by obtaining written consent from employees. If all employees unanimously agree to the publication and the roster is displayed in a secure area inaccessible to outsiders, posting the roster is permissible. However, this does not extend to copying or photographing the roster. These actions could unintentionally make the data accessible to external parties, violating the BDSG.
Copying or photographing a shift schedule containing personal data without permission constitutes a violation of the Federal Data Protection Act.
It is important to note that employees do not have the right to demand the publication of the entire shift schedule or even a copy of it, not even for shift swaps or vacation planning.
This blog post was carefully researched and written with great effort and dedication by the shyftplan team, based on our best knowledge and understanding. However, it does not replace legal advice. If you have important questions about data privacy, it is best to consult a data protection officer or a trusted legal professional.
With shyftplan, the shift schedule is always up-to-date and available online.
Our software elegantly sidesteps the issue of data privacy concerns with publicly posted rosters. Shift schedules are always accessible online and via our app. Data privacy is ensured through access management, which controls and assigns individual viewing and editing rights for employees.
Since personal data is required for a work schedule, data protection naturally applies here as well. A shift schedule should not simply be posted for everyone to see, and it should certainly not be photographed and shared, for example, via messenger—something that often happens in smaller businesses. However, in larger businesses, there can also be problematic interactions between work schedules and data protection. For example, if there is an Excel document that all employees can access and thus view the personal data of others, data protection is violated. Therefore, a shift schedule is a document containing confidential personal data and should be treated as such.
Regarding data protection, the law is clear on work schedules: not every employee is entitled to view the entire shift schedule. Similarly, every employee has the right to prevent the publication of the schedule—even within the company.
• Never post shift schedules publicly • Do not send photos of shift schedules to your employees • Limit employee access to shift schedule files, such as through an intranet • Ensure that each employee can only view their own data A scheduling software can assist in creating a data protection-compliant shift schedule. This is particularly beneficial for larger companies, as smart solutions consider laws and legal requirements when creating shift schedules, helping them stay on the safe side.
